Should a writer dare to create their own covers? You be the judge!
In my post last month, I shared about the process of working with a cover designer for the Rhythms of Redemption Romances. I love those covers, and I hope each of my future covers inspires the same kind of excited wonder I felt when I saw the Rhythms of Redemption covers.
However, not all writers work with a designer. Many brave and multi-talented writers create their own covers, including a number of Inspy Romance authors—and these covers are so good! See for yourself!
(Click any of these covers to start shopping!)
Informed by the process of working with a designer and inspired by the lovely work I saw other authors creating, I decided that with my next release, I would do my own cover design.
Now or Never is a novella that bridges my last series (the Rhythms of Redemption Romances) to my next (The Many Oaks Romances).
I prefer covers with people on them, and they’re one of the popular options in my genre. Since the Rhythms of Redemption Romances all featured photos of people, I figured continuing that would help the new books look like Emily Conrad books.
Unfortunately, I hadn’t made that terribly easy on myself. Now or Never features characters who are around age 50, and the hero is blond. Do you know how hard it is to find a 50-something blond man in a romantic pose on stock photo sites?
Eventually, I found a couple that I thought could work, and I started playing around with variations. Note: the man isn’t blond…
I ran these covers by my writing friends, and the last one got the most votes.
But I didn’t feel that sense of wonder I’d hoped for.
I decided to attempt a different cover style. Could I get away with an illustrated cover? Turns out, even among the illustrated men, blonds are a rarity! I had to finagle an image of blond hair over the top of the illustrated guy’s brown hair, but in the end, I think it worked, and I LOVE this cover. Unfortunately…
It looks like it belongs on a romantic comedy. If you’ve read any of my books, you might know that’s not usually what I write. While Now or Never is on the lighter side of what I write, it’s still not a romantic comedy, and I didn’t want to lure readers in with a false promise.
I went back to the drawing board. What about if I used a scene instead of people?
The next front runner was this cover. I liked the bokeh effect (the soft focus), and the vague impression of a couple in what could be a restaurant or music venue, which fits the story.
I was just afraid it didn’t exactly scream romance.
I tried a couple of other setting covers before inspiration hit.
If I used an out-of-focus shot, as in the cover above, it wouldn’t matter if the couple wasn’t quite the right age. In Canva, I could blur any photo and overlay lights to create a bokeh-like effect. You can bet there was more trial and error, but I finally landed on a cover that I felt matched the story, screamed romance, and gave me that elusive sense of wonder.
Allow me to present Now or Never‘s final cover:
Will leaving positive legacies mean kissing their own happily-ever-after goodbye?
If Tim Bergeron got a lifetime achievement award for anything, it’d be managing the iconic rock band, Awestruck, but he’d trade his successful career for the opportunity to prevent his daughter from repeating his mistakes.
When a health scare proves time is short, he talks Isabella into a cross-country road trip. His attempts to talk her out of a hasty marriage drive a wedge between them, and it looks like the best he can hope for from the trip is scouting out promising new talent to represent. That is, until he meets Gabby.
Widow Gabrielle Voss has responsibilities to her daughter and patients, deep roots in the community, and a dream that scares her. Though she’d never utter it to the people she lives and works among, the truth slips out with Tim, who’s not in Many Oaks, Iowa, to stay.
As her fiftieth birthday party draws near and an attraction to Tim sparks to life, Gabby realizes she must pursue her dream now—or, more reasonably, never.
You can pre-order Now or Never today!
The final cover is cute (and the man is blonde) but I liked the one with a scene and a lot of lights, personally I thought it did look like it was from a romance book although one of the reflective and dramatic kind those usually have scenes on the covers.
I did really like the lights too! My novels do tend toward the reflective and dramatic, so maybe I’ll revisit that style in the future!
I love hearing about the process of developing covers, it’s really interesting, and amazing what you can do to change photos and effects.
When I was younger I used to love L.M. Montgomery’s ‘Emily’ books. I had them in paperback with a picture of a girl (meant to be Emily) on each cover holding a rose. As she got older in each book, the picture got older (no idea how they did this as it was a photo and looked like the same model) and the rose went from a bud to fully blooming. They were beautiful and I can picture them clearly 30 odd years later!
I actually never read Anne of Green Gables (I’ve listened to the audio of the first one now, but I think coming into it in adulthood is different), but I was a big fan of the Emily books! I think the covers on the set I had were different, but those sound lovely.
The one cover I can honestly say totally drew me in was This Present Darkness by Frank Perretti. Totally unlike anything I’d ever read, I actually talked myself out of buying it for about a month. The reason I broke down was a sticker appeared on the book saying if I didn’t like it, I could get a full refund!! It wasn’t until chapter 10 that I finally got so into the book that I didn’t want to put it down!
Sounds like it was an interesting journey from cover love to loving the story inside! Hey, those money-back guarantees can really help sometimes, can’t they? Glad you found a keeper!
Finding a cover that wows you is so hard! It takes so many stock photo look throughs and many mock ups. Love your final cover!
SOOOOO many stock photos! Ha! I never realize how firm my idea is of how a character looks until I try to find a picture to match my mental image.
Love the cover. Thanks for sharing your process!
Thank you, Gail! Glad you enjoyed the behind-the-scenes!
Good morning, I love your book cover especially since you wanted a man with blonde hair and he has blonde hair, I like that you can barely see their faces, that way I can imagine what they really look like. Thank you for sharing your process on your. book covers. One of the most Beautiful covers I have come across is the cover from “Forgiveness Road” by Mandy Mikulencak it is also a very good book. Have a Very Merry Christmas, God Bless you and your family.
I am going to have to look that cover up!! I hope you have a very merry Christmas too!
Thanks for sharing your process. I didn’t realize it could be so involved. Sometimes I read the book and then go back and look to see if the cover matches. Lol
Ha! Keeping us honest, I see 🙂 It is definitely ideal when the cover does match. If only stock photos weren’t so limiting!
something different
It is not out yet, but I saw the cover for The Paris Daughter by Kristin Harmel. Thank you so much for sharing. God bless you. Merry Christmas.
I’m not sure I’ve seen that one, so I’ll look it up! I love checking out impactful covers. Merry Christmas to you too!